Banner
Workflow

Listen to the people, not the numbers

Listen to the people, not the numbers

  • The Indian economy faces an income problem rather than a growth problem.
  • Incomes are not growing sufficiently or sustainably for very large numbers of people.
  • There is an increasing pressure for job reservations for economically weaker sections.

Debates on Job Creation

  • Economists are debating whether the government's policies have led to sufficient job creation, questioning the accuracy of economic data.
  • There is a need to address the root causes of income challenges rather than just relying on historical statistics.

Comparison with the US Economy

  • The US economy, despite positive headline economic numbers, faces citizen dissatisfaction.
    • Therefore, emphasizing the need to measure what matters to common citizens.
  • In the US, dissatisfaction is linked to issues like fair wages and income inequality.

India's Economic Transition

  • India's transition from agriculture to services, bypassing significant movement into manufacturing, has led to income challenges.
  • The policymakers believed in a shortcut from agriculture to services, primarily through the growth of Information Technology services.

Nature of Jobs

  • The problem lies in the nature of jobs created, with a significant portion being low-paying, temporary or lacking social security.
  • The need for sustainable growth involves creating "good" jobs that provide better pay, security and opportunities for skill development.

Changing Economic Paradigm

  • There is a need for a paradigm shift in economic thinking like the importance of new concepts of work and enterprise designs.
  • The world is moving towards more environmentally sustainable and socially harmonious models, requiring a reevaluation of economic relationships.

Value of Caregiving

  • There is a need for valuing caregiving more in the economic paradigm, with attention shifting towards genuine "social" enterprises.
  • The prevailing economic theory distorts social organisations, like families, to suit corporate requirements.

Shift in Policy Making

  • Policymaking needs to start with listening to those undervalued in the current economic paradigm viz. workers, small farmers, entrepreneurs and women.
  • Historical statistics may not guide future policies effectively, hence, policymakers should listen to people's concerns and preferences.

Categories